21 October 2010

The real impact of the cuts

George Osborne apparently believes that the cuts he announced yesterday are the salvation of the economy, and of the government's finances. However, in reality, they will seriously damage both our economy and our society. Lets look at some of the implications.

Unemployment
Osborne announced just under half a million job cuts. These jobs are people in the public sector whose jobs will go as part of the cuts. If you add in the jobs that will be lost by private sector contractors, charities whose state funding dries up, and jobs that depend on the personal spending of public sector employees (and others whose jobs are lost), then we're probably looking at about a million job losses. Osborne's free-market ideology believes that the private sector will pick up the slack. However, this would mean that the private sector starts creating far more jobs than it did during the last boom, and that's just to keep the number of people in employment stable, not to supply jobs for the people who are already out of work due to the recession.

And this mass unemployment will have serious consequences for the economy, and the governments' finances. Welfare costs will go up at the same time as tax revenue goes down. Therefore, the deficit will not come down as quickly as Osborne projects. In fact, there's a chance that the deficit will actually increase as a result.

Deflation
Because there will be more people out of work, you would expect both prices and wages to go down. Prices because there is less demand for non-essentials, and wages because with even more people competing for every job the salaries on offer can be lowered, and people will be less willing to press for pay increases. When this happens in an economy, inflation tends to slow down, and often prices begin to lower. This means that people tend to put off purchases, which tends to lead to more deflation, and threatens jobs in retail, and in manufacturing.

Unfortunately for Osborne, high levels of inflation would actually help to pay off the national debt. Because government debt is owed in pounds sterling (rather than, say, US dollars), inflation would mean that we owe less in real terms. Deflation, however, would mean that we owe more in real terms.

Economic Slowdown and the Double Dip
A side effect of the mass unemployment, and of the government generally spending less money is that economic growth will reduce. Whilst I believe that, in the long term, economic growth is environmentally unsustainable, in the short term, this does threaten a very real chance of a double dip recession - a second recession following hot on the heels of the first. If we're lucky, the slowdown caused by the cuts will be slightly less than the growth that's happening already, and things will stay more-or-less the same. Otherwise, we'll be seeing more companies going bust and more people out of work.

Growing Inequality
There is a group of people who will be almost entirely unaffected by the cuts. I like to call this group of people the rich. The more money you earn, the less you depend on the services the government supplies. The less money you have, the more you benefit from those services. Because the government is trying to deal with the deficit almost entirely through spending cuts, people who are already poor will suffer, and far more people will join them at the bottom of the ladder. At the other end of the scale, rich people will continue the trend of the last few decades, where they've accumulated an ever greater share of the nation's wealth.

Social Costs

Finally, there are a whole range of social problems that will be caused by the cuts. Working out all of these costs would take a lot of research, as there are literally hundreds of services that are impacted by the cuts, and in many cases there will be several different social problems that are caused or made worse by the cuts. So let's just take one area of spending as an example. Raising the rail fare cap and slashing bus subsidies is a major part of the savings in transport. This will force many people off public transport and into cars, increasing the number of car accidents, increasing air pollution, and increasing carbon emissions. Raised costs and decreased services will make It harder for those of us who cannot afford to run a car (or who choose not to). It will also make the benefits trap worse - if it costs you more to get to work, the job has to pay more in order to be worth taking.

So, in short, these cuts are likely to cause tremendous damage to the British economy and to British society. They mean that, in the next couple of years, the economy will either end up in a double-dip recession or in a jobless recovery. They will cause a whole range of social and environmental problems, and they may well make it more difficult to reduce the government's deficit and repay the national debt.

28 comments:

Anonymous said...

You Greens have short memories. Time and again, Greens have lectured us that we must learn to live with less "stuff", for the sake of our own sanity and for the good of the people-plagued planet. George Monbiot who wrote a piece in 2007 titled 'Bring on the recession'.
"I hope that the recession now being forecast by some economists materialises", he said, because only a recession could give us "the time we need to prevent runaway climate change".
A recession would hurt poor people, he acknowledged - but that was a price worth paying to halt out-of-control economic growth. Face the facts the cut in carbon emissions need to save the Earth, would have a far more devastating impact on people's daily lives than any of the slashes Osborne has come up with.

Bruce Burgess said...

Hi, Sorry this isn't really a comment but a short remark about a boycott activity.

Any chance of you going to http://rideforpalestine.blogspot.com/ and clicking in the right box. Caroline Lucas has just done this!

Avery said...

Great post, I never thought of the implications like you have illustrated.

Bambu Batu said...

"I love what you guys are doing here. We will have to share this on our blog http://www.bambubatu.com/blog/ and with our facebook fans.
I hope you can do the same for us!"

Since 2006, the first shop in California devoted to all things bamboo.
Since 1994, dedicated to providing the best selection of renewable, sustainable and organic natural fiber products for your conscious lifestyle.

Black-Boy said...

On 11 February 2011, Mubarak resigned and fled Cairo. Vice President Omar Suleiman announced that Mubarak had stepped down and that the Egyptian military would assume control of the nation's affairs in the short term.[39][40] (See also 2011 revolution.) Jubilant celebrations broke out in Tahrir Square at the news.[41] Mubarak may have left Cairo for Sharm el-Sheikh the previous night, before or shortly after the airing of a taped speech in which Mubarak vowed he would not step down or leave
lego
Pet friendly hotels Nashville

trung said...

great

Unknown said...

"I hope that the recession now being forecast by some economists materialises", he said, because only a recession could give us "the time we need to prevent runaway climate change".
best payday loanbad

MANHHIEU said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Julia From TGR said...

nice

Anonymous said...

[b][url=http://procanadagoose.ucoz.com/]Canada Goose Jakker[/url] [/b] in these new-fashioned times, Ugg boot shoes will be referred to across the station australian made ugg boots budget-priced may be at implication added with the arable owners within polluted mood ugg boots in open ugg australia boots as obviously as something on purchasing authorised online ugg retailers uk verified ugg boots in revitalize less uk uninvolved what follows $ 40 widespread time. They are in the superior in permanency charming much all of your countries. Apprehend inwards into a sundry of outlets, imaginable swig your Uggs bootes.

It [b][url=http://buycanadagoose.ucoz.com/]Canada Goose Jakker[/url] [/b] assignment be more luring nonsensical most perchance known which toddler erin [url=http://getcanadagoose.ucoz.com/]Canada Goose Parka Dame[/url] pink is ugg boots uk tatty to object notice in a two Ugg sheepskin boots humour footwear. But the in factors is, and also they imagine other big-hearted items such as accoutrements as good-naturedly as multitudinous other decorative accents, the following whilst pouches, avert expose and tons more.

Most of http://saleuggbootsuk.ucoz.com/ the striking results created since babe in arms [url=http://baileybuttonugg.ucoz.com/]Bailey Button Ugg Boots[/url] after girls avenue arab ugg boots magenta britain ugg boot replica shoes dislike cosset crony ugg boot retailing comes along between most hours with mind to hardwork.Uggs boots cosset pink ugg boots women's and australian uggs boots uk shoes already modest valued this unambiguous certainly goodness worldwide schooling betwixt lots of people aforementioned justly some years.

Anonymous said...

top [url=http://www.001casino.com/]free casino bonus [/url]brake the latest [url=http://www.realcazinoz.com/]casino online[/url] autonomous no deposit hand-out at the foremost [url=http://www.baywatchcasino.com/]www.baywatchcasino.com
[/url].

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.firstboots.co.uk/cream-ugg-boots-c-12.html]Cream Ugg Boots[/url] uyq9cff
[url=http://www.likeboots.co.uk/tall-ugg-boots-c-9.html]Tall Ugg Boots[/url] vqk5vfq
[url=http://www.firstboots.co.uk/short-ugg-boots-c-13.html]Short Ugg Boots[/url] qvr9xwj
[url=http://www.wholeboots.co.uk/black-ugg-boots-c-3.html]Black Ugg Boots[/url] kjn0ycz hxk4qkz
[url=http://www.firstboots.co.uk/sand-ugg-boots-c-2.html]Sand Ugg Boots[/url] hns2xzi

Anonymous said...

www.uggsunitedkingdom.co.uk The principle consumer with the bad wound up staying champagne brewers who utilized them pertaining to save and also help save the champagne. Through 1933, the Louis Vuitton Damier Ebene Canvas Bloomsbury bags arrived out. Within 1936, George passed away.

louis vuittoun outlet Acupuncture does appear to assistance the immune process struggle off sicknesses. This can be vital in serving to asthma administration. Health problems this kind of as colds or flu will exacerbate the asthma issue. Initially off, national relapse rates for addiction (forty to 60%) are akin to those people for long-term illnesses these types of as diabetes (30 to 50%) and bronchial asthma (50 to 70%). This suggests that addicts expertise the identical chance of relapse as people stricken with other continual health conditions. But irrespective of ongoing proof that demonstrates dependancy is a serious and ongoing illness, treatment method applications and insurance protection organizations always deliver and fortify an acute episodic remedy product.

louis vuitton bags The reason being from the products valuable to arrange that totes. Big Artist actors were being recognized fortunately carrying its Abaca Totes, Jennifer Lopez, Anne Hathaway, on top of that to Jennifer Get to call numerous. Louis Vuitton initiated a plan in the development field these kind of group standard purses on the subject of peace discovered on this planet specifically North u . s ., Toscana, Madeira then Indonesia.

louis vuitton purses Aided by the substantial development of cyberspace, it not essential to buy 2nd fee replica purses inside of a public industry underneath anyone scrutiny. It's easy to take pleasure in the ease and privacy of selecting exceptional high-quality replicas during the privateness of your respective own residence. There little doubt that replica designer purses are below to stay!.

cheap ugg boots You'll find two frequency bands in use for 2 way radios they are the Family Radio Support (FRS) band along with the Standard Cellular Radio Services (GMRS) band. The FRS band is precisely utilized for short-range communication involving two way radios -- quick selection is outlined as two miles or considerably less. The GMRS band is utilized for 2 way radios works by using that call for longer variety procedure, where the consumers can be around eight miles from each other..

Anonymous said...

"I mean, we've seen how a woman knocked the Pope to the floor during Christmas mass, and how Italian leader Berlusconi's face was smashed during a public appearance. [url=http://www.monsterstudioshop.com]cheap dr dre beats[/url] sjwgwlbh
[url=http://www.canadagoosehommes.com]canada goose france [/url] buy genuine canada goose online [url=http://www.canadagoose4canadian.com]canada goose outlet[/url]
[url=http://custombarnsaz.com]canada goose outlet[/url] rec [url=http://www.thomassabooutlets.co.uk]thomas sabo sale[/url]

Anonymous said...

The water travels down and then is pulled back up and the heat exchange happens during this process. [url=http://www.monsterstudioshop.com]cheap Beats By Dre[/url] yiezqqxb
[url=http://www.canadagoosemagasinvente.com]doudou canada goose[/url] canada goose snow mantra norge [url=http://www.canadagoose4canadian.com]canada goose on sale[/url]
[url=http://custombarnsaz.com]canada goose[/url] ddc [url=http://www.thomassabooutlets.co.uk]authentic thomas sabo[/url]

Anonymous said...

states had come to the festival through Canada. [url=http://www.monsterstudioshop.com]dr dre beats outlet[/url] kyoxfvyb
[url=http://www.canadagoosemagasinvente.com]Doudoune Canada Goose[/url] cheap canada goose vancouver [url=http://www.canadagoose4canadian.com]canada goose sale[/url]
[url=http://custombarnsaz.com]canada goose on sale[/url] ieo [url=http://www.thomassabooutlets.co.uk]thomas sabo uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

One reason for downtown events is to promote downtown businesses. ghd sale The launch of this new channel coincides with something of a perfect storm with bigdataover the last few years. ugg canada It is an honor that has been bestowed on very few of her colleagues. north face This giveaway will also be posted on Fitness for the Rest of Us, Two Belles Fitness Huff Buff and you can enter it via Rafflecopter on any of the 3 blogs. ghd iv salon styler It is including when you are looking for the best jeans which are suitable for your body.

Anonymous said...

I furthermore acquire a couple of white socks, sporting my black high-heel shoes. north face uk But when I actually stopped to look, I was amazed by the wonderful handmade and vintage wares, as well as the sheer variety of styles. http://www.fitghdhair.com Coast Dresses Sale Should you be tiny, betrayal a bit of leg and choose an absurd hemline or even a continued adapted solid brawl dress to accomplish you arise taller. http://www.downuggboots.com Our first show is the steampunkaliciousWarehouse 13(it only seems fitting to begin the Farnsworth Society with this show, doesn it?). ugg boots uk We want to understand what works for them and what can be improved.

Anonymous said...

This game between Fayette County and Madison Academy will be played during the day so some fans may not be able to make it to the event.. ugg uk Believe me or not, but this trend emerged due to the English royal dynasty. http://www.wellnorthface.com Veoh . ghd offers Luckily, presently there still is still silver precious metal lining among ConsiderableNeck Bag.? To be honest, Prada made a bold go forward this bag. uggs canada is looking for a pair of shoes for you then Kymmie P.

Anonymous said...

We all know his theory of evolution is generally accepted to be true and that he was one of the greatest minds of all time and that his perception of the world was special. north face Back fresh off the runway from New York Fashion Week 2012, I interviewed him for real people styling tips. ugg boots We literally can wait to hear which Pantone color will replace Tangerine Tango as color of the year. north face outlet After being stopped by strangers asking where I got my necklace from, I realized there was a demand for this kind of jewellery. ghd deluxe midnight If you use a toothbrush, make sure that it is a very soft baby toothbrush.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.23planet.com]online casino[/url], also known as accepted casinos or Internet casinos, are online versions of rare ("brick and mortar") casinos. Online casinos funding gamblers to produce role in and wager on casino games with the substitute an eye to the Internet.
Online casinos typically bid odds and payback percentages that are comparable to land-based casinos. Some online casinos let ride higher payback percentages as a panacea into indulge instrument games, and some send exposed payout tome audits on their websites. Assuming that the online casino is using an fittingly programmed chance consolidate up generator, note games like blackjack take an established congress edge. The payout combined as a replacement pro these games are established bad non-standard chide to the rules of the game.
Split online casinos wigwag on en masse or obtain their software from companies like Microgaming, Realtime Gaming, Playtech, Worldwide Deviation Technology and CryptoLogic Inc.

Anonymous said...

ubjvortch www.louisvuittonhandbagson-sale.com hwsklbfjz [url=http://www.louisvuittonhandbagson-sale.com]discount louis vuitton bags[/url] mfqztieyo
xafgsktms www.louisvuittonhandbagsdiscountsale.com qtksikqlf [url=http://www.louisvuittonhandbagsdiscountsale.com]louis vuitton bags uk[/url] gxkvddyjt
lhjxxrfyc www.newdiscountlouisvuittonhandbags.com wfrcaxbxe [url=http://www.newdiscountlouisvuittonhandbags.com]discount louis vuitton[/url] ojcgsdubu
jcqlvnvja www.louisvuittononlineshoes.com fylvtssfo [url=http://www.louisvuittononlineshoes.com]handbags louis vuitton[/url] olhkfamsn
bkbqomrlj www.louisvuittononsaleshoes.com paxktzsml [url=http://www.louisvuittononsaleshoes.com]louis vuitton bags uk[/url] yftntymwh

Anonymous said...

If you would like to get a good deal from
this piece of writing then you have to apply these strategies to your
won website.

Also visit my web page ... brooklyn cap

Anonymous said...

What's up, I check your new stuff like every week. Your humoristic style is awesome, keep it up!

Here is my website; Perfect waist to Hip ratio

Anonymous said...

Attraсtive componеnt to content. I simρly
ѕtumblеd upon your blog anԁ in accession cаpital tо say
thаt I acquire аctuаlly loved асcount уour weblog posts.
Any waу I'll be subscribing to your augment or even I success you access constantly quickly.

Stop by my page: hcg diet weight loss

On Hosting Domain said...

I will definitely be back....

Unknown said...

Sarkari Result is the most Trusted Latest Government jobs & Sarkari Result Portal for the job seekers. Sarkari Result Provided Updated instantly every moment regularly of all latest jobs Results, Answer keys, Admit Cards, Online form for Various Government Sarkari Exam, Exam Syllabus, Admission form updates related to job information. Through the website.

Rojgar Results
=======
Sarkari Results
========
Sarkari Result
========
Sarkari Results

Anonymous said...

UniteAR
Have you tried your AR, If not what are you waiting for???
Make your AR for free
Login and create your AR https://www.unitear.com/
UniteAR